One of the biggest surprises of the coronavirus pandemic has been the surge of interest in retail seafood, surpassing that of red meat.
It is more and more likely that the boost to retail seafood represents a permanent change in consumer behavior. This provides a real retail opportunity for both supermarkets and the seafood suppliers who deal with them.
Nielsen released data on both the performance of seafood and beef over the 16 weeks ending on June 20, during which most Americans experienced some type of lockdown and then a reopening, which in many areas has not gone well.
The organic growth of seafood sales, subtracting growth in unit prices, was 22.6 per cent over the prior year, while beef was up 21 per cent and the frozen category in general was up 25.8 per cent.
When Nielsen broke down those protein items that had the best performance during that period, three of the top four were seafood: crab, lobster and shrimp.
At a recent Food Marketing Institute (FMI) seafood seminar, I suggested that one of the main drivers of sales of crab, lobster and shrimp was the income support that many Americans received in the first round of pandemic relief. Other economic measures have shown that total spending did not decline, due to the success of the support mechanisms.
In other periods of economic turmoil, a sharp increase in gasoline prices would have a knock-on effect in decreasing sales; this was the opposite. Declining travel and commuter spending, coupled with income support, led to higher sales.
With the virus still not under control in most states, the economic damage is likely to worsen, and the fate of various support programs is very uncertain.
The initial round of income support for unemployed and furloughed workers expires at the end of this month, as do a lot of other protections in terms of mortgage relief, debt payments and eviction moratoriums. Consumer confidence could take a sudden nosedive if the spread of the virus is not addressed.
This means we face continuing disruption into the fall, with many schools not opening and restaurants and bars remaining closed or severely constrained. One worry is that a long-term recession could end up badly hurting spending.

But the other issue is that the longer this pandemic is unresolved, the more locked-in consumers will be to their new spending patterns.
What did the seafood consumer show in this period? They showed that the preponderance of consumption of seafood at restaurants was a convenience, not a fear of cooking. The conventional wisdom was that if there was not someone available to cook and prepare seafood, most Americans would forego it.
That proved not to be the case. Surveys showed that seafood was one of the most missed items in the restaurant shutdown and a subset of consumers moved their consumption to retail.
Secondly, they sought out other sources of seafood, whether through local farmers’ markets or dock sales, or ordering directly from those distributors who pivoted to making direct to consumer sales, such as Pacific Seafood, Cooke and others.
In the past, the breakdown in retail vs. food service consumption, was around 70 per cent food service and 30 per cent retail. If retail’s 20 per cent increase stands up, that may lead to a 35/65 per cent split that would be a big deal for seafood distribution.
What opportunities does this provide for retail seafood?
We can see several.
First is to expand the range and variety of seafood offered. The best retail seafood departments have long recognized that they need a broad range of products, going far beyond the staples of salmon, shrimp and whitefish. Whether it be salmon caviar, varieties of smoked fish, oysters, monkfish or fresh sockeye, strong retail programs are constantly putting new seasonal items in front of their consumers.
Second is to take advantage of the new interest in frozen foods. Frozen seafood can be featured, not thrown on the bottom shelf of an upright freezer, covered in moisture. Some of the frozen food service packs of scallops or swordfish are highly promotable to frozen retail customers.
Third is to partner with local purveyors or feature seafood with a direct story back to its harvest. One of the strengths of premium seafood is its real quality, i.e. it is from a known location, area or season. It is not generic nor produced on an assembly line. Local is a strong marketing message for any seafood item.
Seafood departments have consistently feared that any expansion in fresh will simply drive up what is called shrink, i.e. that they will be left discarding and costing out more seafood and as a result will not gain anything. This problem won’t disappear with more interest in seafood; it just requires hands-on management.
It may mean pricing items multiple times per week, to make sure that the last products are sold. It doesn’t mean not carrying a sufficient number of items. Gaining experience with frozen promotions can help as well.
The opportunity is to change the business model to upgrade the department to support a bigger volume and variety and to build up a virtuous feedback loop where customer satisfaction drives higher sales and return visits, leading to further expansion.
This can be done with either a full-service or self-service department, as long as there is a commitment to quality, breadth and variety.
In short, the opportunity to remake retail seafood is there for those who want to seize it. If they do, it will be a benefit to both retailers and the seafood industry as a whole. An unexpected silver lining in this dark time.
This article was republished with permission of John Sackton and seafood.com.



