Everyone knows that the lobster industry is far more complex than simply setting and retrieving traps.
The multi-billion-dollar Canadian lobster business is a complex web of enterprise with many imperative cogs needed to make the entire system operate smoothly, efficiently and profitably. And if one or more of these cogs is disrupted for some reason, the entire industry can suffer the effects.
One such scenario played out in New Brunswick in 2016 involving a severe shortage of processing workers.
At the time, there were reports that some N.B. lobster processors were considering shipping product outside the province for processing because they simply did not have enough workers to adequately operate their plants.
There were even reports that some plants were so short-staffed that thousands of pounds of lobster had to be thrown out.
New Brunswick Fisheries Minister Rick Doucet said at the time, he knew of one plant that had to discard about 1,360 kilograms of lobster because they couldn’t find enough staff to process the valuable crustaceans.
As a result of such negative impacts, the New Brunswick Lobster Processors Association commissioned a study in 2017 to address this seafood processing industry labour shortage head on.
The report, entitled, Labour Market Challenges and the N.B. Seafood Processing Sector: A Call to Action, explained that lobster processing is a seasonal industry, weather dependent with supply controlled by Fisheries and Oceans Canada and harvesters, requiring seasonal workers to match these factors.

“A key part of that effort has been leadership in discussion and debate about how the changes to the Temporary Foreign Worker Program (TFWP) have impacted the seafood processing sector in the Maritimes. Since the implementation of the program reforms initiated under the previous federal government in 2014, the Liberal government has attempted to lessen the negative impact of the reductions in access to Temporary Foreign Workers (TFWs). In New Brunswick, as in the rest of the Maritimes, plants continue to struggle with finding local workers and face significant hurdles over the timing, administration and restrictions of the current TFWP despite promises from Employment and Social Development Canada (ESDC) that best efforts would be made to better meet industry needs,” the report said.
It concluded with the New Brunswick Lobster Processors Association urging the Government of Canada to abandon the TFW reforms of the previous government and embrace evidence-based policy solutions aimed at generating export sales abroad and economic growth at home.
“By continuing to ensure that Canadians are hired first and that the rights of TFWs are protected effectively, the N.B. seafood sector believes a revised TFWP can operate in a fair and balanced manner.”
The detailed report put forward a number of specific recommendations to the federal government:
- A seafood processing category: The seafood industry in N.B. believes that the unique seasonal nature and processing challenges associated with a perishable product such as seafood require that the sector be subject to its own set of program regulations. While the industry has advocated that the sector should be afforded its own program like the agriculture sector is under the auspices of the Seasonal Agriculture Worker Program (SAWP), program criteria specific to the unique circumstances of seafood processing could be developed in the context of the existing TFWP program.
- Equitable treatment with the agriculture sector: The seafood industry in N.B. believes that as a seasonal industry operating in rural parts of the province, it should have access to TFWs to the same extent and under the same conditions afforded to the agricultural sector under the SAWP.
- A maximum cap of 35 per cent with acceptance of regional necessity: The seafood industry believes the cap on the number of TFWs a plant can have should be increased to 35 per cent. Further, individual plants should be given the flexibility to exceed this cap if their labour market impact assessment (LMIA) demonstrates the existence of the need within their geographic area. As all plants come to terms with their declining local labour markets, they too have and will need to turn to the seasonal labour supply the TFWP provides.
- A fair and appropriate application fee: The seafood Industry in N.B. believes the current fee of $1,000 per TFW is punitive. The seafood sector should be subject to either a flat fee on a plant-wide basis or some type of scaled fee based upon the volume of TFWs. As a starting point, the seafood sector should be charged no more than what the agriculture sector pays for the processing of workers under the SAWP.
- Easier pathways to residency through the TFWP: The seafood industry in N.B. believes that the Government of Canada should work to facilitate pathways to permanent residency for those TFWs having full-time employment.
In response to these challenges that surfaced in 2016, seafood processors in N.B. say that they have dramatically increased their recruitment and retention efforts. They also say that they worked hard to secure non-traditional sources of labour in the face of shrinking labour markets in the communities in which they are located.
“Over 97 per cent of Canadians that apply for jobs get interviewed. Of those that get interviewed, over 95 per cent of Canadians get offered jobs. Despite these efforts, less than 25 per cent of locals that apply for jobs end up completing the processing season,” the commissioned report stated.
As everyone in the seafood processing industry knows, this problem is not just isolated to New Brunswick — almost every fish plant in Atlantic Canada has run into staffing issues at some point, due, in part, to an aging workforce and shrinking rural populations. And this problem is not going to solve itself. It is going to take more proactive action, consultation and understanding by all of the players involved if a solution is to be found to this potentially damaging cog in the seafood processing industry wheel.



